Skip to content

Melamine vs. MDF vs. plywood: which to use

What each panel actually is, how it handles moisture, screws and the saw, and which one belongs on each part of a cabinet: boxes, doors, drawers, backs and shelves.
Type
Guide
Updated
Reading time
7 min
Sections
8
On this page (8)

Ask ten cabinetmakers which sheet good is best and you’ll get ten answers, mostly because the honest answer is “depends on the part.” A good cut list mixes materials: one panel for the boxes, another for the doors, something thin for the backs. The shop behind Zeder Studio works with melamine and MDF every day (we don’t build in solid wood), so this guide is written from that side of the trade, plus what you need to know about plywood to decide when it’s worth the extra cost.

What each panel actually is

Melamine (TFL)

“Melamine” describes the surface, not the core. It’s a particleboard or MDF core with decorative paper saturated in melamine resin fused to both faces under heat and pressure, which is why US suppliers also call it thermally fused laminate, or TFL. You get a finished, wipeable surface straight off the saw in white, solid colors or wood-grain patterns. That makes it the default for frameless boxes, closet systems and shop furniture.

  • Melamine on particleboard: the common, budget-friendly version. Great for boxes, shelves and closet parts.
  • Melamine on MDF: denser, more uniform core. Cleaner edges, better machining and better screw holding in the face. Costs and weighs more.

Raw MDF

Medium-density fiberboard is made from fine wood fibers and resin pressed into a flat, uniform panel with no grain, knots or plies. It routes cleanly, holds a crisp profile and takes paint beautifully, which is why it’s the go-to for painted shaker doors, routed door designs and thermofoil (vacuum-pressed PVC) fronts. The trade-offs: it’s heavy, the dust is very fine (run dust collection and wear a mask), and the edges soak up finish unless you seal them first.

Raw particleboard

The bare core of most melamine. Cheap, flat and stable, but weak at screw holding in the edge and unforgiving with water: once it swells, it stays swollen. You rarely see it bare in finished work; it shows up in hidden structure or as a substrate for laminate and veneer.

Plywood

Plywood is built from thin veneers glued in cross-grain layers. That gives it the best screw holding of the group, good stiffness and less weight than MDF of the same thickness. On the downside, it costs more, face quality varies by grade, the edges show the plies (you’ll band them, veneer them or add a hardwood lip) and lower grades can hide voids. Many US cabinet shops build boxes from prefinished hardwood plywood; exterior-glue panels hold up better to moisture. Watch the thickness, too: nominal ¾ in plywood often measures 23⁄32 in, and your dado and part math should use the real number.

Hardboard and thin backs

Cabinet backs are usually ⅛ to ¼ in: hardboard (one smooth face), thin MDF, or thin panels with a melamine face to match the box interior. A back’s job is to keep the box square and close it off, not to carry load.

Moisture-resistant (MR) boards

Both particleboard and MDF come in moisture-resistant grades, often with a green-tinted core so you can tell them apart. They handle humidity and the occasional splash better, but they’re not waterproof: standing water on an unsealed edge will still ruin them. They’re worth it for sink bases, bathrooms and humid climates.

Side-by-side comparison

Melamine / particleboardMelamine / MDFRaw MDFRaw particleboardPlywood
MoistureLow (better in MR)Low-medium (better in MR)Low (better in MR)Very lowMedium-high (better with exterior glue)
Screw holdingFair; weak in edgeGood in face, fair in edgeGood in face, fair in edgeWeakBest
FinishPrefinishedPrefinishedPaint, lacquer, thermofoilNeeds a surfaceClear coat, stain, paint
EdgesAlways bandBandSeal and paint, or bandBand or coverBanding, veneer or solid lip
WeightMediumHighHighMediumLow
On a panel sawNeeds a scoring blade to avoid chippingClean with a scorerClean; lots of fine dustEasyFace can splinter; use a fine blade
Relative costLowMediumMediumLowestMedium-high
Typical usesBoxes, shelves, closetsDoors and fronts, better boxesPainted or routed doorsHidden structureHeavy-duty boxes, vanities

This is a qualitative guide: quality swings widely between brands and even between panels of the same type. When in doubt, ask your supplier for the spec sheet and test an offcut.

Which panel goes where

Cabinet boxes

For most kitchens and closets, ¾ in (or 5⁄8 in) melamine on particleboard does the job, and you get a finished interior without spraying anything. Step up to melamine on MDF or to plywood when the box carries heavy loads, gets assembled and knocked down more than once, or has lots of hardware screwed into its edges.

Sink base

The cabinet that takes the most abuse. Use MR board for the bottom and sides, band every edge of the bottom (back edge included) and caulk the cutouts around the plumbing. If the budget allows, exterior-glue plywood is the toughest option.

Doors and drawer fronts

Melamine on particleboard works for budget slab doors as long as all four edges get a heavy band. For large or higher-end doors, melamine on MDF warps less and leaves a cleaner edge. If the design calls for paint, lacquer, profiles or grooves, raw MDF is the natural pick.

Drawer boxes

Melamine drawer sides around 5⁄8 in work well with full-extension slides and a ¼ in bottom captured in a groove or screwed on. For drawers that hold pots or tools, a thicker bottom keeps it from bellying.

Backs

Hardboard or thin MDF, nailed or stapled on the back or set in a dado. If the cabinet is open or the back shows, use a thin panel with a melamine face that matches the interior.

Long shelves and sag

Particleboard and MDF creep under load more than plywood does. A rule of thumb many shops use: keep loaded ⅝ in melamine shelves under about 30 to 32 in of unsupported span. Beyond that, go thicker, add a center support, glue a stiffening strip under the front edge or switch to plywood.

Clear shelf span = inside width − clearance
36 in cabinet, ¾ in sides: 36 − 2 × ¾ = 34½ in inside
Shelf at 34⅜ in → over ~32 in loaded: stiffen it or split it
24 in cabinet: 24 − 2 × ¾ = 22½ in → shelf at 22⅜ in, no problem

Clean cuts: chipping and the scoring blade

Melamine’s surface is hard and brittle. Where the blade exits the bottom face, it pulls out small chips. On a panel saw or sliding table saw, the fix is the scoring blade: a small blade ahead of the main one that scores a shallow groove in the bottom face just a hair wider than the main cut. Keep both blades sharp, use teeth designed for laminated panels, and without a scorer put the good face up and slow the feed. Every blade also turns material into dust; that kerf belongs in your sheet math.

Joinery and fasteners

  • Confirmat screws: the go-to case screw for panel goods. They need a stepped bit and must enter dead center in the edge.
  • Cam locks (minifix): for knock-down furniture or cabinets assembled on site. Require accurate face and edge boring.
  • Particleboard screws: coarse, deep thread, always with a pilot hole when going into an edge.
  • Dowels and glue: strong, hidden joints that work well in MDF.

Edge treatment by panel

Cutting melamine always exposes the core, so every visible edge gets banded, and in wet areas the hidden ones too. Raw MDF edges can be sealed and painted or banded. Plywood gets banding, veneer tape or a hardwood lip. Choosing type, thickness and width, and working out how much to buy, is covered in edge banding types and how to calculate it.

Thicknesses and sheet sizes

In the US, ¾ in is the standard box thickness, with ⅝ in common for melamine and drawer parts, mostly on 4 × 8 ft (48 × 96 in) sheets. In Mexico, melamine is usually 15–16 mm or 18–19 mm on 1830 × 2440 or 1220 × 2440 mm sheets. Either way, confirm actual size and thickness with your supplier before you design, because parts depend on them. The sheet sizes guide covers the details, and the sheet calculator gives a quick estimate.

Put it in your catalog

In Zeder Studio, each panel you stock lives once in the materials catalog with its size, thickness, grain, kerf and trim, shared by Cut, Design and Quote. So if the sink base is MR board and the doors are MDF, each part is optimized on its own sheet and priced at its own cost. See how in the materials catalog, and look up any unfamiliar term in the glossary.

Save this, optimize the cut list and quote it in Zeder Studio.

Frequently asked questions

Is melamine or MDF better for kitchen cabinets?

It depends on the part. Melamine on particleboard is the practical, budget choice for boxes and shelves; raw MDF is better for painted or routed doors, and melamine on MDF for higher-end fronts.

Is melamine waterproof?

No. The face shrugs off splashes, but the core swells if water gets into an unsealed edge. Use moisture-resistant board for sink bases and band every edge.

Is plywood better than MDF for cabinets?

Plywood holds screws better and weighs less, but it costs more and its face isn’t as smooth for paint. MDF wins for painted doors; plywood wins for heavy-duty boxes and wet areas.

Why does melamine chip when I cut it?

The blade tears the brittle surface as it exits the bottom face. A properly aligned scoring blade, sharp blades with teeth made for laminated panels, and the good face up if you have no scorer will fix most of it.

What is the green MDF or particleboard?

It’s usually a moisture-resistant grade tinted green so you can tell it apart. It handles humidity and splashes better than standard board but isn’t waterproof.

Cut better starting with your next job

Create an account and use the full Workshop plan for 14 days. No card; afterwards you drop to the Free plan, not a lockout.